- ID Book
- Dedicated to
- Acknowledgement
- Preface
- Discourse One Criticism and Investigation about Propaganda of Silence of Amirul Momineen (a.s.)
- Doubts Created Regarding Silence of Amirul Momineen (a.s.)
- Doubts Created Regarding Silence of Amirul Momineen (a.s.)
- First Category: Conjectures that claim ‘Letting go of Caliphate linked with consent’
- Second Category: Conjectures that claim ‘Detachment of Amirul Momineen (a.s.) from Caliphate and overlooking it, after six months of Abu Bakr’ Caliphate’
- Third Category: Conjectures that claim ‘Absence of plan of right of Caliphate and not proving the School of Imamate’.
- Did Amirul Momineen (a.s.) Leave Caliphate and Overlook his Rights?
- Correct Analysis about Ali’s reaction to Usurpation of Caliphate
- CONCLUSION
- Footnote
- Doubts Created Regarding Silence of Amirul Momineen (a.s.)
- Correct Interpretation Ali’s Silence and its Causes
- Correct Interpretation Ali’s Silence and its Causes
- Amirul Momineen (a.s.) and his Stern Refusal to Pay Allegiance to Abu Bakr
- Amirul Momineen (a.s.) and Declaration of Illegitimacy of Caliphate
- Final Judgment on Silence of Amirul Momineen (a.s.)
- To what extent Ali Believed in Preserving Silence?
- Did Ali Refrain from Arguing about Imamate?
- Footnote
- Are Shias obliged to avoid discussion on Caliphate…?
- Are Shias obliged not to Debate on Imamate?
- Discourse Two Criticism and Scrutiny of Analyses Propagated about Consultation of Caliphs with Ali
- What does Scrutiny of Statistics show?
- A) Items of Abu Bakr’s Consultation with Imam Ali (a.s.)
- B) Items of consultation of Umar with Imam Ali (a.s.)
- Did the Second Caliph always consult Ali? Did he always accept his view?
- C) Instances of Uthman consulting Amirul Momineen Ali (a.s.)
- Results of Statistical Analysis
- Final Analysis about Caliphs’ Consultation with Amirul Momineen (a.s.)
- Theological Reminder
- Differences between the Aims of Caliphs and Ali Regarding Consultations
- Footnote
- Discourse Three Criticism and Scrutiny of Analyses Publicized regarding Ali’s cooperation with Caliphs’ Government
- Analysis of Ali’s participation in Caliphs’ Government
- Was Ali given a Governmental responsibility during the tenure of the Caliphs?
- Did Amirul Momineen (a.s.) have Positive Outlook to Battles of Caliph’s
- Criticism and Scrutiny of Ali’s Positive Outlook to Battles[1]
- Participation of Hasan and Husain (a.s.) in battles of Caliphs[1]
- Scrutiny of Participation of Ali’s Companions in Battles and Government of Caliphs[1]
- Scrutiny of Participation of Ali’s Companions in Battles and Government of Caliphs[1]
- Did Amirul Momineen (a.s.) Always Attend Caliphs’ Prayers?
- Discourse Four Scrutiny and Criticism of Analyses Publicized in Respect of Relations between Caliphs and Amirul Momineen (a.s.)
- Examples of statements in Sunni sources about Zahra’s anger on Abu Bakr
- Aim of Amirul Momineen (a.s.) in taking over the Guardianship of Muhammad bin Abu Bakr?
- Did the Second Caliph desire Ali to be Caliph after him?
- Did the Second Caliph desire Ali to be Caliph after him?
- Scrutiny of the legend of Second Caliph’s Marriage with Umme Kulthum
- A) The prosperity in the next world for Umar by means of this marriage
- B) Immunity of Second Caliph about crimes committed against Ahle Bayt (a.s.)
- C) Suggestion of Umar having gained the satisfaction of Ahle Bayt particularly that of Hazrat Zahra (s.a.)
- D) Baraat, a principle of Shia belief now is put under question
- E) Enmity and rancor of Umar towards Ali is covered
- F) To show relations between Ali and Umar to be friendly
- G) Giving legitimacy to Umar’s Caliphate and distancing it from the term of usurpation
- Can only marriage with bin Hashim be a proof of friendship?
- Criticism and Investigation
- View of the first category of Shia scholars
- Why this rumor gained currency?
- Outlook of second category of Shia scholars
- Opinion of Ustad Sayyid Ali Husaini Milani[52]
- How many daughters did Ali have named Umme Kulthum?
- Outlook of Ayatullah Marashi Najafi
- Another Analysis about the Marriage of Umme Kulthum with Umar
- Part C) Relations of the Third Caliph with the House of Divine Revelation
- A glance at historical documents
- Footnote
- Discourse Five Publicized Analyses about the relation of Amirul Momineen (a.s.) with Caliphs
- A) Ali’s criticism of Caliphs
- Why Ali named his sons after Caliphs?
- Name of Muawiyah in use
- Name of Yazid in use
- Another outlook about these namings
- C) Are narrations attributed to Ali about his praise of Caliphs correct?
- Part A: Narrations in Sunni books
- Part B: Narrations mentioned in Nahjul Balagha and Al-Gharaat
- The Researcher Shushtari’s outlook
- D) Had Ali accepted the legitimacy of Caliphs’ Government?
- The text of the Imam’s letter to Muawiyah copied from Waqatus Siffeen
- Conclusion
- Footnote
- Final conclusion Zahra’s Martyrdom is not Fiction
A VICTIM LOST IN SAGHIFAh V.2
ID Book
Labbaf, Ali,
A Victim Lost in Saqifah/ Ali Labbaf; Translated by Hassan Najafi.-Qum: Ansariyan, 2008.
576 P.
ISBN: 978-964-438-976–8
Original Title: مظلومی گمشده در سقیفه
1. Saqifeh Bani Sa’edeh. 2. Ali ibn Abitaleb, Imam I. 599
– 661 – Proof of Calihpate. I. Najafi, Hasan, Tr.
294.452 BP 223.54 .L3
Dedicated to
Zahra (s.a.) who bore most pains until the moment of her martyrdom because of Saqifah.
Fatima Research and Study Group
Acknowledgement
p: 1